Skip to content

Preparation

Do you need coaching for the selective test?

Is coaching necessary for the NSW selective or OC test? What the NSW, WA and Victorian test bodies say, what tutoring can and can't do, and a home plan instead.

By Scholaroo editorial team · Published · 6 min read

Dates and formats checked against official sources on . Confirm with the official links before you register.

No, you don't need coaching for the selective test. The NSW Department of Education says coaching or tutoring for the selective and OC placement tests "is not necessary", and the WA Department of Education and ACER (which runs the Victorian exam) give similar advice. What does help is knowing the test format well, which a family can manage at home with the free official practice material.

That said, tutoring isn't wrong, and plenty of families use it. This guide sets out what the official bodies say, what the research found, what coaching can and can't do, and a home plan for families who'd rather go it alone.

What does the NSW Department of Education say about coaching?

The NSW department says coaching is not necessary, does not give an advantage, and is not recommended or endorsed by the department.

On its selective high school and opportunity class practice test pages, the department says:

  • "coaching or tutoring for the placement test is not necessary"
  • "extra paid coaching outside of school will not give your child an advantage"
  • "The department does not recommend or endorse coaching for the placement test"
  • "There is no credible research that shows coaching helps a child gain entry"
  • "too much coaching can harm their wellbeing"

Both pages add that "a child who is coached and gets in is likely to have got a place anyway". The department also says students "do not have to study any extra maths concepts" and that Thinking Skills needs no previous knowledge.

Instead, it points families to its free practice tests and the Student Resource Hub, which has interactive quizzes, practice items and test-taking tips. It also asks families to make sure children attend school regularly in the lead-up to the test.

What did the NSW review find about coaching?

The department's 2018 Review of Selective Education Access found "little evidence that coaching substantially improves test scores", but also found that familiarity with the test made a real difference to how students felt on the day.

The review's findings are more nuanced than a simple yes or no:

  • The evidence is thin. It said it is "difficult to find evidence that coaching helps students achieve higher test scores", partly because test-takers are not asked whether they were coached.
  • Overseas research suggests a small effect. Studies in other countries suggest commercial test preparation "may have a small positive effect on test scores", but the review cautioned these findings "might not hold true in NSW".
  • Predictable tests are easier to coach. Coaching is more likely to help "where the test's format and question types are more predictable".
  • Familiarity matters. Coached students described confidence with timing and question types. Students with no preparation "were often surprised by questions and the test format, ran out of time, and struggled to understand questions".

In response, the department committed to "continuing to ensure that coaching is not required for entry" and to "reducing the potential for predictability and coachability in the test design". The review also said that from 2020 the department would procure a new test "designed to the highest international standards for precision and accuracy".

The practical lesson: the advantage the review saw came from not being surprised. Your child can get that from official practice and a few timed run-throughs, with or without a tutor.

What do Victoria and WA say?

Both are cautious about coaching and recommend their own free materials instead.

TestWho says itWhat they say
WA GATE (ASET)WA Department of Education"We do not endorse or recommend any form of private professional coaching or tutoring services." The best preparation is to "read carefully through the ASET Handbook and try the Practice ASET."
Victorian selective entryACER, for the Victorian Government"There is no need for your child to practice or revise for the exam." ACER offers free sample questions so students can become familiar with the question style.
ACER scholarship testsACER"short-term training for the tests is unlikely to improve performance". A candidate's best preparation "is to read widely and think critically".

The WA department also says the ASET "identifies a student's potential, rather than their acquired knowledge", and that practice test results "do not show how an applicant will score".

What can coaching do, and what can't it do?

Good coaching can add structure, feedback and familiarity; it can't add a place, and it can't replace years of reading and thinking.

What a good tutor can help with:

  • Structure and routine, for families who find it hard to keep a plan going.
  • Feedback on writing. This is the hardest part to mark at home, and an experienced reader can help a lot.
  • A specific weak spot, such as fractions or a particular reasoning question type.
  • Exam technique: pacing, skipping and returning, and planning a timed piece of writing.
  • Social benefit. Some students in the NSW review said they enjoyed learning alongside friends.

What coaching can't do:

  • Guarantee a place. No one can, and the departments set out to make the tests hard to coach.
  • Replace broad skills. Reading widely, number sense and reasoning take time to build.
  • Make up for exhaustion. The NSW department warns that too much coaching can harm wellbeing, and a tired child reasons less well.

We haven't included typical tutoring costs here because we couldn't find a credible, independent source for them.

How can my child prepare at home?

Most of what the tests ask for can be practised at home in short, regular sessions using the free official material.

A simple home plan:

  1. Start with the official material. Look through the department's or ACER's test description and practice tests together, untimed.
  2. Build skills a little at a time. Two or three sessions a week, 20 to 40 minutes, rotating reading, maths reasoning and Thinking Skills. Our thinking skills guide explains the question types.
  3. Write weekly, to time. The NSW selective test has a 30-minute writing task. Plan, write, check. Read your child's piece aloud together and talk about what worked.
  4. Review every mistake. Sort each one: didn't know how, misread it, or ran out of time. Each needs a different fix.
  5. Add the clock in the last two to three months. Timed sections, then two or three full mocks a few weeks apart, using the official practice test as one of them.
  6. Ease off in the final week. Early nights and the logistics.

Our 10-week preparation plan goes through this in detail, and when to start preparing covers the longer run-up. For the test format itself, see the NSW selective test guide.

How do I choose a tutor if we decide to use one?

Choose someone who knows the current test, explains mistakes rather than just setting more work, and never promises a result.

Questions worth asking:

  • Do they teach the current format? The NSW tests are computer-based, and the selective test has four parts: Reading, Mathematical Reasoning, Thinking Skills and Writing. Old paper-test material can mislead.
  • How do they give feedback on writing? Ask to see a marked example.
  • How much homework is there? More is not better for a primary-age child.
  • Do they review mistakes? A score on its own teaches nothing.
  • What do they claim? Be wary of guaranteed results or "predicted" places. Practice results don't predict the real test.
  • Is your child happy to go? If it's causing dread, it's costing more than it gives.

Practise in the test format

Whichever way you go, a tutor or at home, the free official practice tests are the place to start. When your child is ready for more, Scholaroo has practice questions, timed mock tests in the test format, and feedback by topic, so you can see which areas need work. Practice builds familiarity; it can't guarantee a place.

Frequently asked questions

Is coaching necessary for the NSW selective test?

No. The NSW Department of Education says coaching or tutoring for the placement test is not necessary and that extra paid coaching outside school will not give a child an advantage. It provides free practice tests instead.

Is tutoring necessary for the OC test?

The department gives the same advice for the OC test: coaching is not necessary, and it does not recommend or endorse it. Its free online OC practice tests and the Student Resource Hub are designed to help children become familiar with the test.

Can my child prepare for the selective test at home?

Yes. Reading widely, solid maths reasoning, short regular writing, and practice in the real test format with the official materials cover what the tests ask for. Many families do this without a tutor.

Is selective coaching worth it?

It depends on the child and the family. The NSW department says coaching gives no advantage, but some families use a tutor for structure, feedback on writing, or help with a specific weak area. It is a choice, not a requirement.

Does the Victorian selective exam need coaching?

ACER, which runs the exam for the Victorian Government, says there is no need for your child to practise or revise for it. It offers free sample questions so students can get used to the question style.

What should I look for in a selective tutor?

Look for someone who knows the current test format, gives clear feedback on writing, reviews mistakes with your child rather than just setting more tests, and is honest that no one can guarantee a place.

Official sources

Get the free Scholarship Prep Kit

We'll email you the kit and occasional scholarship-prep tips. Unsubscribe any time.