Preparation
Critical reasoning: a guide to thinking skills questions
How to answer critical reasoning questions in NSW Selective and OC Thinking Skills: conclusions, assumptions, strengthen and weaken, and 12 reasoning flaws.
Critical reasoning questions are part of Thinking Skills in the NSW Selective test and the NSW OC test, and similar questions appear in the reasoning sections of scholarship tests. They're the part most students find least familiar, because they don't test a school subject. They test how carefully you read an argument.
The good news: the questions come in a small number of types, and each type has a method.
The parts of an argument
- Premises are the reasons or evidence.
- The conclusion is what the writer wants you to accept.
- An assumption is a missing step the writer takes for granted.
Our school's library is always full at lunchtime (premise), so the school should build a bigger library (conclusion).
Assumption: a full library means students would use more space, and not, say, that it's the only air-conditioned room.
Conclusion signals: therefore, so, thus, this shows that, consequently, we should. Premise signals: because, since, as, given that, for example.
The question types
1. Main conclusion
"Which statement best expresses the main conclusion?"
Find the sentence everything else supports. Test: say [conclusion] because [premise]. If it reads naturally, you've found it. The wrong answers are usually premises, or a step on the way.
2. Drawing a conclusion
"Which of these must be true, based on the passage?"
Choose only what the text guarantees. Answers that are probably true, true in real life, or go further than the text are traps.
Every student in the chess club is in Year 6. Some Year 6 students play football.
Can you conclude some chess club members play football? No. The football players might all be outside the club.
3. Identifying an assumption
"The argument relies on which assumption?"
The negation test: turn each answer into its opposite. If the opposite would break the argument, that answer is the assumption.
Lena practised every day this term, so she'll win the spelling bee.
Assumption: the other competitors didn't practise as much. If they practised more, the argument fails.
4. Strengthening
"Which, if true, most strengthens the argument?"
Look for an answer that closes the gap between the premises and the conclusion, often by confirming the assumption or ruling out another explanation.
5. Weakening
"Which, if true, most weakens the argument?"
Look for an answer that breaks the link: an alternative cause, a counter-example, or evidence that the assumption is false.
Since the new crossing was installed, accidents near the school have fallen. The crossing has made the road safer.
Weakens: the speed limit near the school was also lowered at the same time. That's another possible cause.
6. Spotting the flaw
"Which best describes the error in the reasoning?"
Name the reasoning mistake, not a factual one. The flaws to know are in the table below.
7. Matching arguments
"Which argument uses the same reasoning?"
Strip the argument to its shape, for example All A are B; C is A; so C is B, then find the answer with the same shape, whatever its topic.
8. Applying a principle
"Which situation follows the principle?"
Restate the principle as a rule ("if this, then that") and check each option against every part of it.
Twelve reasoning flaws
| Flaw | What goes wrong | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Correlation, not causation | Two things happen together, so one is assumed to cause the other | Ice-cream sales and sunburn both rise in summer, so ice-cream causes sunburn. |
| Hasty generalisation | A big conclusion from too few cases | My two friends hated the movie, so everyone will. |
| Slippery slope | One step is assumed to lead to an extreme outcome | If we allow phones at lunch, soon nobody will ever talk again. |
| Attacking the person | Criticising the speaker, not the argument | Don't listen to her view on recycling; she's only twelve. |
| Straw man | Misrepresenting an argument to make it easier to attack | "We should have less homework." "So you want students to learn nothing?" |
| Red herring | Changing the subject to distract | Why worry about the leaky roof when the garden looks so nice? |
| Bandwagon | It must be right because many people do it | Everyone is buying these shoes, so they must be the best. |
| Circular reasoning | The conclusion is used as its own reason | He's trustworthy because he always tells the truth. |
| Irrelevant authority | Trusting someone who isn't an expert on this topic | A famous footballer says this diet is healthy, so it is. |
| Appeal to ignorance | No proof against it, so it must be true | No one has proved ghosts don't exist, so they do. |
| False choice | Only two options are offered when there are more | Either we cancel the excursion or it will rain on us. |
| Shifting meaning | A word changes meaning partway through | A feather is light. What is light can't be dark. So a feather can't be dark. |
If-then logic
Many questions turn on one rule. From "If it rains, the match is cancelled":
| Statement | Valid? |
|---|---|
| It rained, so the match was cancelled. | ✓ Yes |
| The match wasn't cancelled, so it didn't rain. | ✓ Yes (the contrapositive) |
| The match was cancelled, so it rained. | ✗ No: it might have been cancelled for another reason |
| It didn't rain, so the match went ahead. | ✗ No: same reason |
All and some: "All A are B" doesn't mean "all B are A". All kangaroos are mammals, but not all mammals are kangaroos.
Trap answers to watch for
- True, but irrelevant. It may be a fact, but it doesn't affect this argument.
- Too extreme. Words like always, never, all and proves usually go further than the passage.
- Half right. The first part fits, but the second part contradicts the text.
- Out of scope. It's about a different group, place or time from the argument.
- Agrees with the view, but doesn't help. Supporting the conclusion's opinion isn't the same as strengthening the argument.
A method for every question
- Read the question first, so you know what you're looking for.
- Find the conclusion and underline it in your head.
- Name the gap: what has the writer taken for granted?
- Predict what the answer should do before reading the options.
- Eliminate with the traps above, then choose.
Pace: NSW Selective Thinking Skills has 40 questions in 40 minutes, and the OC test has 30 in 30, so aim for about a minute a question. If one is taking much longer, make your best choice, flag it and move on.
Logic puzzles
Thinking Skills also includes problem-solving puzzles: ordering people in a queue, seating plans, timetables and codes. Draw it. A quick grid or line diagram turns a paragraph of clues into something you can check at a glance. Start with the clue that fixes something definite ("Ava is last"), and leave "not next to" clues until the end.
For vocabulary, the other half of verbal reasoning, see our vocabulary guide. Then practise Thinking Skills questions, each one marked as you answer with an explanation of the reasoning.
Frequently asked questions
What is critical reasoning in the NSW selective test?
It's part of the Thinking Skills test, which the NSW Department of Education describes as critical thinking and problem solving. Critical reasoning questions give a short argument and ask you to find its conclusion, an assumption it relies on, what would strengthen or weaken it, or the flaw in its reasoning.
How do you find the main conclusion of an argument?
Ask what the writer wants you to believe, and which sentence the others are reasons for. Words like 'therefore', 'so', 'thus' and 'this shows that' often introduce it. Test it by putting 'because' after it: the conclusion plus 'because' plus the reasons should make sense.
What is an assumption in critical reasoning?
An unstated idea the argument needs in order to work. To test an answer, imagine it were false: if the argument falls apart, it's the assumption.
What are common reasoning flaws?
Confusing correlation with causation, generalising from too few examples, slippery slope, attacking the person instead of the argument, misrepresenting the other side (straw man), offering only two options when there are more, and arguing in a circle.
