Preparation
Selective writing test tips: formats, marking and prompts
How the writing task works in the NSW selective test, WA ASET and ACER, Edutest and AAS scholarship tests, how it is marked, a planning method and 8 prompts.
Dates and formats checked against official sources on . Confirm with the official links before you register.
The selective and scholarship writing tests ask your child to write one or two short pieces, to a strict time limit, in response to a topic, picture or statement they haven't seen before. The NSW Selective High School Placement Test, the WA ASET, and the ACER, Edutest and AAS scholarship tests all include writing, with times from 15 to 40 minutes. Across all of them, the biggest single rule is the same: write about the prompt you are given.
Below: the writing format for each test, what the official sources say about marking, a planning method, eight original practice prompts, common mistakes, and how to give useful feedback at home.
Which selective and scholarship tests include a writing task?
Most of them do, but the time, the number of pieces and the format differ a lot from test to test.
| Test | Pieces | Time | Format | What the prompt looks like |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NSW Selective High School Placement Test | 1 | 30 minutes | Typed on computer | A topic to write about "according to the instructions" |
| WA ASET (Communicating Ideas in Writing) | 1 | 25 minutes | Handwritten, pen or pencil | An image, a piece of text, or both; any style or genre |
| Victorian selective entry exam | 2 | 40 minutes for both | Answers go in a supplied answer booklet | Not described publicly |
| ACER scholarship (Levels 1 to 3) | 2, set as separate tests | ACER's example questions refer to 25 minutes allowed | About one and a half A4 pages of ruled paper per piece | A picture, a statement or both |
| ACER scholarship (Primary, Years 3 to 5) | 2, in different genres | 40 minutes in total | Not stated on ACER's sheet | Two separate prompts |
| Edutest | 1 | 15 minutes, no planning or reading time | Written response | May be creative, descriptive, narrative, persuasive, expository or informative |
| AAS | 1 long-form piece | 25 to 30 minutes | Blue or black pen (pencil allowed) on paper; some schools test online | Not described publicly |
A few notes. The NSW Opportunity Class (OC) test, sat in Year 4, has no writing section. The Victorian exam is sat in Year 8 for entry to Year 9, so it's a long way off for most readers of this page. Scholarship schools choose their own timetable and sometimes their own components, so always confirm the details with the school.
For the full picture of each test, see our NSW selective test guide, WA ASET guide and ACER scholarship test guide.
How is the selective writing test marked?
Each provider publishes its own criteria, but they all reward relevant, well-organised ideas expressed clearly, and they all penalise writing that ignores the prompt.
Here is what each official source says, in its own terms:
- NSW selective: the test assesses "the creativity of the student's ideas", their ability to "write effectively for a purpose and audience", and their "use of language for effect". The department's practice test video adds text structure, grammar, punctuation, style and vocabulary. Writing that doesn't address the topic "will be marked lower, regardless of their fluency or creativity."
- WA ASET: each response is scored by at least two trained markers, on relevance to the prompt; the complexity, freshness and interest of the ideas; style and form; the strength of the plot, message, issue or information; organisation and coherence; voice and tone; and the expressiveness and fluency of the language. The handbook says spelling, grammar and punctuation have little impact if the work is readable. Off-topic or plagiarised work can score zero.
- ACER scholarship: markers consider thought and content, structure and organisation, and expression, style and mechanics (grammar, punctuation, sentence structure). Writing not developed from the stimulus is penalised, and quality matters more than length. At Primary level, ACER assesses the quality of the content and ideas and the structure of the expression.
- Victorian selective: ACER says the writing assesses "the ability to convey ideas in precise language with ideas organised coherently."
- Edutest: punctuation, creativity, construction, grammar, spelling and relevance to the task.
- AAS: genre and structure, arguments, vocabulary, sentence structure and cohesion, syntax and tense, punctuation and spelling.
So the emphasis shifts a little. The ASET leans hardest on original ideas; Edutest and AAS put more weight on accuracy. But a piece that clearly answers the prompt, has a shape, and is written with care does well against every list.
What is a good planning method for a timed writing test?
Use a short, repeatable routine: read, pick one idea, sketch a shape, write, then check.
This version works for a 25 to 30 minute task. Shrink it for Edutest's 15 minutes, and use it twice for the two-piece tests.
- Read the prompt twice (1 minute). Underline what the task actually asks for. In NSW the instructions say what to write, so a persuasive task needs a persuasive piece.
- List three ideas, then choose one (1 to 2 minutes). The first idea is usually the one everyone else has. The WA ASET handbook specifically suggests not going with the first idea that comes to mind.
- Sketch a shape (1 to 2 minutes). For a story: opening, problem, turning point, ending. For a persuasive piece: position, two or three reasons with an example each, conclusion. For a description: one place or moment, three senses, a closing image. Keep it to a few words per line.
- Write (most of the time). Start close to the action. Keep the prompt visible in the piece, not just in the first line.
- Check (2 to 3 minutes). Read it back. Fix missing words, full stops and any sentence that doesn't make sense.
On the ASET, markers never see the plan, and the handbook says to plan only if it helps. In Edutest's 15 minutes, a plan is ten seconds of notes in the margin at most.
What do selective and scholarship writing prompts look like?
They are usually short and open: a picture, a phrase or a question, with room for different kinds of response.
These eight practice prompts are original and written for Scholaroo. They are not from any official or past paper. Picture prompts are described in words; you could find a similar photo to use instead.
- Statement (story or reflection): "The door had been locked for as long as anyone could remember."
- Picture (any form): A pair of muddy gumboots sitting outside a closed front door, in the rain.
- Persuasive: "Every school should have one day a term with no screens at all." Do you agree or disagree? Write to convince your principal.
- Phrase (any form): "Small things matter."
- Letter with a purpose: Write a letter to your local council about one change that would make your neighbourhood better for children.
- Picture (description or story): An empty swing moving gently in a playground just after sunset.
- Statement (argument or story): "The best ideas often begin as mistakes."
- Explanation: Explain to a younger student how to do something you are good at, so that they could do it themselves.
Set prompts 3, 5 and 8 when practising for NSW, where the instructions say what kind of writing is needed. Use the open prompts (1, 2, 4, 6, 7) to practise choosing a form, as the ASET and ACER allow. For Edutest, run any of them on a 15-minute timer.
What are the most common mistakes in the writing test?
The costly mistakes are about relevance and time, not fancy vocabulary.
- Writing a rehearsed piece. A memorised story with the prompt squeezed into one line is exactly what NSW, ACER and the WA ASET warn against. Practise generating ideas, not polishing one script.
- Ignoring the instruction. If the NSW task asks for a persuasive piece, a great story still misses the purpose and audience.
- Losing the prompt halfway. The link to the prompt should run through the piece. The ASET handbook says markers must be able to see that the prompt is central.
- Running out of time. An unfinished piece usually reads worse than a shorter, complete one. ACER says quality is more important than length.
- Over-planning. Five minutes of planning in a 15-minute test leaves too little time to write.
- One big paragraph. Even a short piece needs a beginning, middle and end that a marker can see.
- Ignoring accuracy where it counts. Edutest and AAS both list spelling and punctuation. Leave time to check.
How can parents give useful feedback on practice writing?
Keep feedback short, specific and tied to one goal at a time, so your child wants to write again next week.
- Read it aloud together. Your child will hear missing words and clumsy sentences themselves.
- Start with the prompt. Ask: "Where does this piece answer the prompt?" If neither of you can point to it, that is the main fix.
- Two strengths, one next step. Name exactly what worked ("your opening drops us straight into the storm") and choose a single thing to improve next time.
- Use the criteria, not your taste. A quick checklist from the marking lists above works well: relevant, clear shape, interesting idea, careful language, checked.
- Don't rewrite it for them. Ask questions instead: "What could the reader see here?" or "What's your strongest reason?"
- Keep a folder. Date each piece. Looking back after a month shows progress more clearly than any score.
- Match the test's conditions. Practise typing for NSW and handwriting for the ASET. For scholarship tests, ask the school whether it runs on paper or online.
One timed piece a week, with a short conversation afterwards, is plenty for most children in Year 5 or 6. For a wider plan across all sections, see our preparation guide, and for building word choice, our vocabulary guide.
Practising writing with instant feedback on Scholaroo
A parent reading every piece is the best feedback, but it isn't always possible every week. Scholaroo marks practice writing straight away, against the criteria for the test your child is preparing for.
- Your child types a response to a timed prompt, sometimes a picture, with the time limit of their test.
- Each piece gets a mark out of 5 for each criterion, with a comment that points to something in the writing, one thing that worked and one or two things to change next time.
- The criteria follow each provider's published list: ACER's three elements, WA's ASET criteria grouped into four, and what Edutest, AAS and NSW say they assess. Victoria publishes no criteria, so its writing is marked on ideas, structure, language and accuracy.
- It is practice marking, not the provider's. No provider publishes its score scale, so the marks out of 5 are Scholaroo's. Use the comments to choose the next thing to work on, rather than as a prediction of the real result.
Writing tasks count like any other practice test. There's no separate limit on writing.
You can try it free: start a 7-day trial and choose the writing section for one of its practice tests. The multiple-choice sections have practice questions and timed mock tests in each test's format too, with feedback by topic. Practice builds familiarity; it can't guarantee a place.
Frequently asked questions
How is the NSW selective writing test marked?
The NSW Department of Education says the writing test assesses the creativity of the student's ideas, how effectively they write for a purpose and audience, and their use of language for effect. Writing that does not address the topic is marked lower, however fluent or creative it is.
Can my child memorise a story and adapt it on the day?
It is risky. The WA ASET handbook says responses must be original and impromptu, and that rehearsed pieces with a forced link to the prompt get very low scores. NSW and ACER also mark down writing that doesn't come from the topic or stimulus.
How long should a selective or scholarship writing piece be?
No provider sets a word count. ACER says quality matters more than length, and the WA ASET handbook says one to two pages is usual, though a very short piece may not give markers enough to assess.
Does spelling count in the writing test?
It depends on the test. Edutest and AAS list spelling and punctuation among the skills they assess, and ACER includes the mechanics of English. The WA ASET handbook says spelling, grammar and punctuation have little impact as long as the work is readable.
Should my child plan before writing?
A short plan helps most children, but keep it brief. In Edutest's 15 minutes there is no separate planning time, and the WA ASET handbook notes markers never see the plan, so it is only worth doing if it improves the writing.
Is the selective writing test typed or handwritten?
The NSW selective test is computer-based and the writing is typed. The WA ASET is a paper test and the writing is handwritten in pen or pencil. For scholarship tests, check with the school, because some run on paper and some online.
Official sources
- NSW Department of Education: Selective high school practice tests (opens in a new tab)
- NSW Department of Education: The placement test (opens in a new tab)
- WA Department of Education: Gifted and talented testing (opens in a new tab)
- WA Department of Education: ASET Handbook (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
- ACER: Victorian selective entry exam preparation (opens in a new tab)
- ACER: Scholarship Tests, Written Expression (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
- ACER: Scholarship Tests, Primary (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
- ACER: Scholarship Tests example questions (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
- Edutest: Information for parents (opens in a new tab)
- Academic Assessment Services: Scholarship testing guide for parents (opens in a new tab)
- Academic Assessment Services: Scholarship tests (opens in a new tab)
